Meditations on Metta
Metta meditation, the first of the brahmavihara series of meditations focused on developing positive emotional states, begins by cultivating love for oneself. But, for many people, the first stage is the most difficult to practice.
Why is this? What does this say about our society? In the early suttas and meditation manuals the authors take for granted that this is the easiest stage. For somebody who was claiming to negate this self, why did the Buddha emphasize the importance of self love?
The Buddha opposed domination. A person who truly deeply, fundamentally, and unshakably loves themselves is not someone who can be easily dominated, nor are they the kind of person who would wish to dominate others. Cultivating healthy, non-possessive, open love for oneself is the basis of a practice for the liberation of all beings. Without this base, love for others becomes weak and co-dependent: Our ability to be empathetic is hindered by the dependence of self-worth on the external approval and dependence of others.
The self which the Buddha sought to overcome was the Atman, the universal self of the Brahmins, taught in the early Upanishads, which he learned from his teachers and from his society. This transcendent cosmic self, synonymous with God, Brahma, is on its own a beautiful thing, but the Buddha saw its insufficiency: he saw how despite the so-called spiritual equality it promoted, domination based on caste, gender, economic, and political inequality were rampant in his society. And so the Buddha had to imagine a form of freedom which went beyond the Absolute self. The only true or real self, the only self which could actually be the base for liberating action, was just this limited, relative, impermanent, and flawed karmic self. Only by seeing this self’s limitations and accepting them could one find that truly unshakable confidence required of a social revolutionary: by not depending on others for one’s happiness, one could take any risk; one could give up anything; one could transgress any social boundary that needed to be transgressed without fear. Indeed, metta was first taught in the suttas as a practice for cultivating fearlessness.
Domination occurs in the mind. It may be reinforced by objects in the material or social worlds. It may be instigated by violence, coercion, intimidation, abuse, symbolic control, ritual, drama narrative. All of these are what the Buddha called himsa, the intention to harm others. But none of them are domination themselves. Domination, and its twin, submission, occur only in the minds of the dominator and the dominated. This is why it is so so important to train the mind if we wish to overcome domination.
Merely nonviolent attitudes are not enough. Buddha emphasized non-violence so strongly because he was a khattiya — a warrior. His conditioning as a child was to be a warrior: to use violence to solve problems; to protect others; to enforce the law; to enforce caste; to enforce domination. Many of his first followers were from his own clan the sakyas, and non-Buddhists frequently referred to the entire religion, regardless of clan, as sakyas. Sakyas were also warriors, and the Buddha was training them to abandon the duty (dharma) of their caste. He was training them to break the most fundamental law of Brahmanism. By teaching non-violence he was teaching the warriors to renounce the will to dominate others. But he most emphatically did not teach them to be submissive and weak. The Buddha taught the sakyas about the inner strength which comes from self-love which makes one absolutely indomitable. He did not compare himself or his followers to animals like dear and doves. Instead, they were taught to be like lions like wild elephants, like bulls, like cobras — they were powerful, indomitable, unshakable warriors. well established in a new kind of strength.
Strength rooted in love and freedom is exactly this kind of subjectivity which anarchism seeks to cultivate in its adherents. Not passive, not submissive, not compromising — but fearless.

